Skip to content

Audit ADR, DDD, internal and user documentation against implementation #211

Description

@pacphi

Queue this work after the dashboard effort in #210 is complete and merged. Do not begin the comprehensive audit as part of that PR.

Audit the full documentation set against an exact current implementation baseline: ADRs, DDD documents, internal architecture/engineering guides, and user-facing documentation. Treat source code, tests, actual command/help output, current integrations, and authoritative upstream contracts as evidence; documentation is not proof of implementation.

Scope:

  • Inventory and classify all documentation and its intended audience/authority.
  • Reconcile architectural decisions and DDD boundaries with implementation, including Proposed/Accepted/Implemented/Superseded status and dates.
  • Find stale, contradictory, overstated, unsupported, or missing claims across guides, API/data contracts, configuration/ownership rules, host capabilities, safety boundaries, and UI behavior.
  • Validate commands, examples, defaults, prerequisites, configuration paths, links, source citations, screenshots, and troubleshooting guidance.
  • Distinguish configured/cached state from runtime facts, and supported behavior from experimental or planned capabilities.
  • Update documentation coherently without silently modifying code to make old claims true; record implementation defects separately.

Acceptance:

  • A coverage matrix lists audited documents, implementation evidence, findings, and disposition.
  • Findings are prioritized by user impact and authority/safety risk, with concrete source references.
  • Corrected documentation agrees across ADR, DDD, internal, and user-facing layers.
  • Runnable examples and documentation checks are validated where practical; unavailable verification is explicitly recorded.
  • An evidence-backed PR records the exact baseline, validation, and remaining gaps.

Requested as a separate follow-up during #210. The current dashboard PR remains responsible only for documentation directly affected by its own changes.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions